There are lots of excellent books for children out in the world. I would define "excellent" in a couple of different ways, but to really earn the title, a book should be interesting, funny, heartwarming (or in general make you feel some true emotion deeply). And a book needn't have all of the above, but it should have SOME of these elements. Kate Albus' middle grade novel A Place to Hang the Moon got just about the highest recommendation I could think of a few years ago from a trusted source (a fellow Cybils judge) online, so I immediately bought it. It then sat unread on my shelf for three years. *crying emoji* Luckily, a young person I know and love just turned ten and is a voracious reader, just like the characters in this book, so I picked up off the shelf and finally read it... so that we could have a wonderful chat about it when she does. And now that I know personally how lovely it is, I can't wait to see what she thinks.
It is 1940 and William, 12, Edmund, 11, and Anna, 9, aren’t terribly upset by the death of the not-so-grandmotherly grandmother who has taken care of them since their parents died.
But the children do need a guardian, and in the dark days of World War II London, those are in short supply, especially if they hope to stay together. Could the mass wartime evacuation of children from London to the countryside be the answer?
It’s a preposterous plan, but off they go– keeping their predicament a secret, and hoping to be placed in a temporary home that ends up lasting forever. Moving from one billet to another, the children suffer the cruel trickery of foster brothers, the cold realities of outdoor toilets and the hollowness of empty stomachs.
But at least they find comfort in the village lending library– a cozy shelter from the harshness of everyday life, filled with favorite stories and the quiet company of Nora Müller, the kind librarian. The children wonder if Nora could be the family they’ve been searching for... But the shadow of the war, and the unknown whereabouts of Nora’s German husband complicate matters.
A Place to Hang the Moon is a story about the importance of family: the one you’re given, and the one you choose.
Anna, Edmund, and William (listed in order from youngest to oldest, and William at a lofty 12-years-old!) are siblings growing up in the midst of London during World War II. They've been sheltered while living at their grandmother's house (because they are orphans), but now she's dead as well and they don't have a guardian. Never mind the bombs being dropped by German planes! So, they join a troop of kids from a nearby school and are evacuated to the countryside. An unlikely goal also resides in their hearts – to find a forever home in their billet, with a family who thinks "hang the moon," as their dead parents used to say. Of course, wanting something and making it happen are two different things.
Although Albus doesn't describe the countryside sparsely, per se, she saves her description mostly for interior scenes (with a few notable exceptions – rat-catching, for one!), and so most of the book indoor activities and interpersonal interactions. It is through these interactions that the reader really takes the measure of the siblings. William, responsible, solid, and a little bit anxious – made into a parent for his younger siblings and feeling the strain. Edmund, irrepressible and without filter, and with a strong sense of justice (and injustice). Anna still with some little girl softness and optimism that William especially doesn't want to crush. These children are thrust into life as evacuees, with no backup plan, and so they make the best of it – experiencing sometimes wonderful and at times awful things in search of a forever home.
One thing the author does particularly well is to incorporate books and a love of reading (and there are different flavors of this in each of the children) into the book in general. Allusions to the books that would have been popular in the 1940s are woven throughout the story and suffuse the book with a warmth and sense of time that makes it feel, as much as a modern book can, of that era. I told a friend of mine that it has Narnia vibes. There isn't a magic wardrobe, but the sibling adventures (and squabbles, of course) as well as the countryside away from the bombing and without parents – these things align. The mentions of A Little Princess throughout mirrored the wish-fulfillment that the children experienced, and heightened the emotional weight of the story. Albus knows how to turn on the waterworks. Also, I want to assure you, dear reader, that yes, there is a happy ending!
Something I am always thinking of, as an IB teacher, is who the intended audience of a text is, and how that may change its meaning. As an adult, I am not the intended audience for this story, but I found it extremely charming, cozy, and heartwarming. I believe its intended audience will find it an adventure and a half – American youngsters typically won't have experience (or even generational knowledge of) with gas masks, evacuations, rat-catching, victory gardens, and more. But with such a lovely story attached, they may become curious about these foreign objects and activities and end up enamored with the time period and/or historical fiction in general.
In all, A Place to Hang the Moon is a cozy, heart-wrenching gem of a story that calls back to the classics of the middle grade genre.
Recommended for: young people ages 8 and up who like sibling stories, adventures, and who understand the joy of reading a good book. Would be an excellent bedtime read aloud as well, for children ages 7 and up.
